my strategy was to look for something low-effort (or stuff I had lying around already) that people might be willing to jump a hoop for.

Low-effort is good! I am not up for extended interaction with patrons. It will burn me out very quickly and it runs heavily against my degree of comfort as an introvert who doesn't let that many people that deeply into their life anyway.

Anyway, best wishes.

Thank you. I really appreciate all of the suggestions. If the rewards don't need to be thematically related to the main output of the Patreon, I'm sure I can find something.