Basically, although I really enjoy the show, I think (fear/suspect?) the writers have a problem making characters that are mixed (that have both likable and unlikable traits)--they seem to be able to make all-around pleasant characters or conniving nasty ones, but nothing in between.
Hm. I may not be able to watch it, then, unless they improve—I don't do well with straight-split light-or-dark characterizations. My favorite characters are always mixed even when they wind up inexplicably on the positive side. If Thomas being complicated is out of character, I don't know.
but then, when I think of the alternative--an angel-of-light gay guy--and when I think of the writers' apparent penchant for martyrdom (Mr. Bates!), then I come to the conclusion that if they'd made him a good guy, they'd have made him a martyr to his gayness, and a huge victim.
True. At least when you're being a bastard, you're doing something.
no subject
Hm. I may not be able to watch it, then, unless they improve—I don't do well with straight-split light-or-dark characterizations. My favorite characters are always mixed even when they wind up inexplicably on the positive side. If Thomas being complicated is out of character, I don't know.
but then, when I think of the alternative--an angel-of-light gay guy--and when I think of the writers' apparent penchant for martyrdom (Mr. Bates!), then I come to the conclusion that if they'd made him a good guy, they'd have made him a martyr to his gayness, and a huge victim.
True. At least when you're being a bastard, you're doing something.